Volume 3, No. 8 August 2024 (1725-1739)![]()
p-ISSN 2980-4868 | e-ISSN 2980-4841
https://ajesh.ph/index.php/gp
The
Effectivity of Outpatient Waiting Time in Hospital through Online or Web-based Reservation
(Literature Review)
Nadiya
Nabila1*, Dumilah Ayuningtyas2
1,2Universitas Indonesia, Depok, West
Java, Indonesia
Email: nadiyanabila@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
The issue
of long waiting times for outpatients remains a prevalent problem in healthcare
services, particularly in hospitals. This can be mitigated through the
implementation of an effective patient scheduling system, such as an online or
web-based scheduling system. However, such systems are not widely utilized and
have not received significant attention in Indonesian healthcare services,
especially in public healthcare services. This study aims to identify the
advantages of an online reservation system and determine the influential
factors for developing an effective outpatient scheduling system for patients.
A literature review was conducted using a systematic approach, searching
through databases such as PubMed, ProQuest, and Scopus for publications from
the past 5 years. The initial search using keywords "online
reservation" OR "web-based reservation" OR "appointment
system" AND "outpatient" AND "waiting time" AND
"hospital" yielded 85 relevant literature sources. The PRISMA
framework was then applied to narrow down the selection to 9 relevant
literature sources, which were reviewed in-depth. The findings revealed
numerous advantages of implementing an online scheduling system, including
increased patient satisfaction, enhanced patient-centeredness, reduced patient
absences, decreased workload for doctors and medical staff, among others. This
review suggests that there are numerous advantages to implementing online or
web-based reservation systems, as well as various types of online scheduling
systems that can be applied and implemented in healthcare services. Practical
implications and suggestions for further research are also discussed in this
study.
Keywords: Complications, Elderly Patients, Knee Arthroplasty.
INTRODUCTION
Hospitals, as institutions
in the healthcare sector, are fundamentally designed to ensure consumer or
patient satisfaction and comfort in every service they provide. Patient waiting
time is one of the crucial factors that can influence patient satisfaction and
comfort. Numerous studies have indicated that extended patient waiting times
have a negative impact on patient satisfaction within a healthcare setting
Patient waiting time, especially
the consultation waiting time (between registration and waiting for
consultation/treatment), is greatly influenced by patient scheduling system. Samadbeik, et al.
An effective scheduling system is a
needed solution for a service to reduce patient waiting time, and it also
enhances the utilization of resources such as staff and other resources
In Indonesia, the use of websites or
applications in both private and government hospitals has started to develop.
However, it is sometimes not well optimized due to the absence of standardized
scheduling practices, and this issue has not yet been prioritized. This is in
line with Alfiansyah's research
In accordance with the transformation of the
Indonesian healthcare system in 2024, the utilization of digital information
needs to be optimized to support an integrated health data system. This
literature review aims to explore the use of online scheduling, the advantages
of implementing an online scheduling system that encourages hospitals in
Indonesia to address this issue, and the factors that contribute to the
efficiency of online scheduling.
RESEARCH METHODS
The study was conducted using the Literature Review with systematic
approach to examine the efficiency of patient waiting time through online
reservations using the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systemic Reviews
and Meta-Analysis) method. The databases used for research sources were PubMed,
ProQuest, and Scopus.
In this study, research questions were formulated to facilitate the
achievement of research objectives related to the selected topic. The research
questions focused on examining the effectivity of patient waiting time in
hospitals/clinics with the implementation of online reservations. The search
process involved using keywords such as "online reservation" OR
"web-based reservation" OR "appointment system" AND
"outpatient" AND "waiting time" AND "hospital."
The inclusion criteria for selecting relevant literature were studies that were
published within the past 5 years (2018-2023), full-text availability, and
English language journals. The exclusion criteria included journals that are
focuses on scheduling systems in general, rather than specifically on web-based
or online-based appointments.
After the search process, the retrieved results based on Boolean logic were
imported into the Mendeley Reference Manager to check for duplicates using the
software. Two authors independently selected the literature based on its
relevance to the research needs of the literature review. Following the initial
selection based on abstracts and titles, a further screening was conducted
based on the full text of the studies to ensure the eligibility of literature
selection. The process of literature selection and screening will be documented
and summarized using the PRISMA flowchart.
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Figure 1. Inclusion with PRISMA
guideline (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table
1. Result
|
No |
Author, years |
Title |
Origin |
Objectives |
Registration system utilized |
Advantages |
|
1 |
Jin, Ha- Jun, et. Al., 2021 |
Effect and satisfaction of
outpatient services by precision valuation reservation registration |
China |
Developing patient
registration processes to reduce waiting times, thereby enhancing patient
satisfaction and medical staff performance. |
Precision reservation
registration by following the patterns observed in the outpatient department,
several visit intervals of 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, or 10 minutes are obtained. |
Minimize the concentration of
patients in the morning at the outpatient clinic and decrease the queue length Decrease patient’s waiting
time, thus can enhance patient’s satisfaction, alleviating feelings of
irritability and anxiety caused by prolonged waiting Improve satisfaction of
medical staffs, creating peaceful and efficient treatment environment Ensure orderly treatment
processes, including precise diagnosis and suitable treatment |
|
2 |
Ye, Qing dan Hong Wu, 2022 |
Patient’s decision and
experience in the multi-channel appointment context: An empirical study |
China |
|
Online and offline
registration system |
Facilitates doctors in effectively
managing service capacity, reduce the additional burden on the healthcare
system Balance the demands between
online and offline channels can avoid overload situations, improve efficiency
of healthcare service by optimizing online and offline processes) Patients can get more information via the
online appointment channel and chances to choose a satisfied doctor (internet
can provide certain results) The reduction of patient
waiting time, improve satisfaction, reduce the aggravation of patient’s
conditions caused by uncesessary waiting time |
|
3 |
Akintomide, Akintunde O, et. Al., 2019 |
An audit of the appointment
booking system and patient waiting time in an ultrasound unit in Nigeria: A
need to eliminate congestion in our public hospitals |
Nigeria |
Assess the appointment
scheduling system and other factors contributing to queues in the ultrasound
department and their impact on patient waiting times. |
Online registration system
with 30 minutes interval for each patient |
Decrease patient congestion
(by an efficient allocation into blocks and time slots interval) Shorter waiting times Improving patient
satisfaction Patient allow to choose a convenient day and
time for their examination, allow them to manage their booking, which will
reduce the rate of “no-show” and cancellation |
|
4 |
Bagheri, Fatemeh, et. Al.,
2022 |
The use of various
appointment |
Iran |
Determine the use of the
appointment systems by patients visiting the outpatient centers
and to examine the perspective and the satisfaction of the users of these
systems. |
Web- based appointment
system, Interactive Voice Record (IVR), and Unstructured Supplementary
Service Data (USSD) appointment systems |
Positive effect on patient’s
satisfaction Reducing no-shows Reducing waiting time Reducing staff workload 24-hour access to the
systems |
|
5 |
Garavand, Ali, et al., 2021 |
E-booking Websites in Iranian
Public Clinics: A Step Toward Health Equity |
Iran |
Analyse the situation of
e-booking websites in Iranian public clinics |
Internet-based e-booking
system in the hospitals (e- health) |
Prevent congestion of
healthcare centers, and thus, they could be a
barrier to the spreading of communicable diseases, especially in the COVID-19
pandemic Reduction of patients’
waiting time Decrease in waste of
resources Increase in patients’
satisfaction |
|
6 |
Leung, Winnie, et al., 2019 |
Improving Access to
Healthcare with On-line Medical Appointment system |
Australia |
Design patient scheduling
methods to ensure that sufficient space is reserved for walk-in patients,
while at the same time, seeing as many patients as possible. |
Improve the process of making
medical appointments for small or medium size medical clinics or centers – a critical aspect to increase healthcare
quality, efficiency, flexibility and decrease cost |
Improves flexibility for the
patient as they can make an appointment online without restricting to
business hours Reduction of waiting times, improved
patient satisfaction. Improved hospital performance,
better quality of service. Reduce throughput time and
better use of capacity. Activities can be executed
faster, increase communication speed, increase information availability,
reduce duplicated data entry, reduce human error and offer a more predictable
result |
|
7 |
Su, Wei., at al., 2020 |
Who Misses Appointment Made
Online? Restrospective Analysis of the Outpatient
Department of a General Hospital in Jinan, Shandong Province, China |
China |
The key factors related to
missed appointments made on the Internet appointment system of a general
hospital in Jinan, Shandong Province. |
Outpatient Online Appointment
system |
Improves the efficiency of
hospital services Reduces patient congestion, shortens
wait times, enhances patient experiences Reduces the rate of no-shows |
|
8 |
Kwak, Jin Kyung, 2023 |
Analysis of the Waiting Time
in Clinic Registration of Patients with Appointments and Random Walk-Ins |
Korea |
Investigating whether the
clinic registration system can be improved by separating the queues and
resources for scheduling patient and walk-in patient |
Outpatient scheduling system
and offline appointment (walk-in appointment) |
Can possibly save time of walk-in patients while minimizing
the time lost for patients with appointment |
|
9 |
Su, Huiqiao,
et al., 2019 |
Online scheduling for
outpatient services with heterogeneous patients and physicians |
China |
Design a scheduling policy
for the outpatient scheduling (both online and walk-in), while considering
the heterogeneity of both patient and healthcare providers |
Online scheduling system with
Markov decision process (MDP) |
Reduce the average waiting
time per served patient, without increasing the number of deferred patients,
thus it has lower total cost Reduce physicians overtime
working |
The search results using Pubmed,
Proquest and Scopus yielded a total of 85 articles
relevant to the keywords. The next step involved removing duplicates using
Mendeley Reference Manager, resulting in the exclusion of 9 articles. The
evaluation was then conducted based on the titles and abstracts for research
relevance, leading to the identification of 50 irrelevant articles. From the
remaining 35 articles, a comprehensive assessment and review of their content
were performed. The evaluation and review revealed that 26 articles mostly
explained about appointment system in general, rather than specifically about
online or web-based appointment. Literature on this topic was gathered with
inclusion criteria for the last 5 years, and the PRISMA results identified
three relevant articles. These 9 articles were published within the past 3
years, indicating the ongoing and emerging relevance of online reservations.
Four articles were conducted in China, two of them were from Iran, and the
others were conducted in Nigeria, Australia, Korea.
Two of the nine
articles
Discussion
Many
factors can affect patient waiting time, including a shortage of medical staff,
a high patient volume, computer usage, and a lack of discipline among medical
staff
One of the advantages of using online reservations, as found in all
articles
Another advantage widely
found in the 7 articles
Furthermore, according to
Ye, Qing, et al.
According to the research conducted by Jin, et al.
Another
factor that influenced by the use of online
reservations is the reduction in patient no-show incidents during scheduling.
This condition is described in studies by Akintomide,
et al.
In the research by Su, et al.,
CONCLUSION
Healthcare institutions should develop and optimize
the implementation of online registration systems, considering the numerous
benefits they offer. The effective utilization of online reservations is
expected to optimize patient waiting times, reduce staff workload, and enhance
the overall effectiveness and efficiency of hospital services. Specific
advantages include increased patient satisfaction, reduced no-show rates, and
improved management of patient flow. To successfully adopt this system, hospitals
can establish regulations by introducing web-based patient registration
mechanisms, which not only regulate patient demand but also empower patients to
conveniently make appointment reservations. Practical steps include investing
in user-friendly technology, training staff, and ensuring data security. By
doing so, hospitals can provide patients with a multitude of advantages,
significantly enhancing their overall healthcare experience. Further research
is needed to identify best practices, overcome potential barriers to
implementation, and optimize the use of online-based reservation systems to
ensure their effectiveness and sustainability.
REFERENCES
Akintomide,
A., Ukweh, O., & Efanga,
S. (2019). An audit of the appointment booking system and patient waiting time
in an ultrasound unit in Nigeria: A need to eliminate congestion in our public
hospitals. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, 8(6),
2055. https://doi.org/10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_235_19
Alfiansyah,
G., Pratama, M. R., & Swari,
S. J. (2021, January 6). Web-Based Patient Registration System Design Based
on National Standards of Hospital Accreditation at Balung
Hospital Jember in Indonesia.
https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.210101.014
Bagheri, F., Behnam, F., Galavi, Z., & Ahmadian, L. (2022). The use of various
appointment systems among patients visiting academic outpatient centers in
Kerman and the evaluation of patients’ perspective and satisfaction. BMC
Health Services Research, 22(1).
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-022-08635-6
Cao, W., Wan, Y., Tu, H., Shang, F.,
Liu, D., Tan, Z., Sun, C., Ye, Q., & Xu, Y. (2011). A web-based
appointment system to reduce waiting for outpatients: A retrospective study. BMC
Health Services Research, 11.
https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-11-318
Garavand,
A., Aslani, N., Ayyoubzadeh,
S. M., & Abhari, S. (2021). E-booking websites
in iranian public clinics: A step toward health
equity. Shiraz E Medical Journal, 22(8).
https://doi.org/10.5812/SEMJ.106925
Jin, H. J., Cheng, A. L., Qian, J. Y.,
Lin, L. M., & Tang, H. M. (2021). Effect and satisfaction of outpatient
services by precision valuation reservation registration. World Journal of
Clinical Cases, 9(26), 7750–7761.
https://doi.org/10.12998/wjcc.v9.i26.7750
Kwadwo Tenagyei,
E., Kusi, K., & Agbeshi Rutherford, P. (2021).
Design and Implementation of Hospital Reservation System on Android. In International
Journal of Computer Science and Information Security.
Kwak, J. K. (2023). Analysis of the
Waiting Time in Clinic Registration of Patients with Appointments and Random
Walk-Ins. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,
20(3). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20032635
Laeliyah,
N., & Subekti, H. (n.d.). Waktu Tunggu Pelayanan Rawat Jalan dengan Kepuasan Pasien Terhadap Pelayanan di Rawat Jalan RSUD Kabupaten
Indramayu (Vol. 1, Issue 2).
http://journal.ugm.ac.id/jkesvo
Leung, W., & Nøhr,
C. (2019). Improving access to healthcare with on-line medical appointment
system. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, 257,
271–276. https://doi.org/10.3233/978-1-61499-951-5-271
Mardiah,
F. P. (2013). The Analysis of Appointment System to Reduce Outpatient Waiting
Time at Indonesia’s Public Hospital. Human Resource Management Research,
2013(1), 27–33. https://doi.org/10.5923/j.hrmr.20130301.06
McMullen, M. J., & Netland, P. A. (2015). Lead time for appointment and the
no-show rate in an ophthalmology clinic. Clinical Ophthalmology, 9,
513–516. https://doi.org/10.2147/OPTH.S82151
Menteri Kesehatan Republik Indonesia Nomor : 129/Menkes/SK/II/2008 TENTANG.
(n.d.).
Peng Zhao, Ms. 1 I. Y. P. corresponding
author1, 2 J. L. P. M. 3 B. J. L. P. M. 4 and E. S. Ms. (2017). Web-Based
Medical Appointment Systems: A Systematic Review. J Med Internet Res, 19(4).
Peter Idowu, A., Olusegun Adeosun, O.,
& Oladipo Williams, K. (2014). Dependable Online Appointment Booking
System for Nhis Outpatient in Nigerian Teaching
Hospitals. International Journal of Computer Science and Information
Technology, 6(4), 59–73. https://doi.org/10.5121/ijcsit.2014.6405
Samadbeik,
M., Saremian, M., Garavand,
A., Hasanvandi, N., Sanaeinasab,
S., & Tahmasebi, H. (2018). Assessing the online outpatient booking
system. Shiraz E Medical Journal, 19(4).
https://doi.org/10.5812/semj.60249
Sousa, P., Kuiper, A., Li, Z., Wu, H.,
& Ye, Q. (n.d.). Patient’s decision and experience in the multi-channel
appointment context: An empirical study.
Su, H., Wan, G., & Wang, S. (2019).
Online scheduling for outpatient services with heterogeneous patients and
physicians. Journal of Combinatorial Optimization, 37(1),
123–149. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10878-017-0216-z
Su, W., Zhu, C., Zhang, X., Xie, J.,
& Gong, Q. (2020). Who misses appointments made online? Retrospective
analysis of the outpatient department of a general hospital in Jinan, Shandong
Province, China. Risk Management and Healthcare Policy, 13,
2773–2781. https://doi.org/10.2147/RMHP.S280656
Susanti, Y., Azis,
Y., & Kusnadi, dadang.
(2015). Pengaruh Appointment Registration System terhadap Waktu Tunggu dan Kepuasan Pasien. Global
Medical and Health Communication, 3(1).
Ye, Q., Wu, H., & Li, Z. (n.d.). Patient’s
decision and experience in the multi-channel appointment context: An empirical
study.
Yeon, N., Lee, T., & Jang, H.
(2010). Outpatients Appointment Scheduling With
Multi- Doctor Sharing Resources. Winter Simulation Conference.
Zhang, X., Yu, P., & Yan, J.
(2014). Patients’ adoption of the e-appointment scheduling service: A case
study in primary healthcare. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics,
204, 176–181. https://doi.org/10.3233/978-1-61499-427-5-176
Zhao, P., Yoo, I., Lavoie, J., Lavoie,
B. J., & Simoes, E. (2017). Web-Based Medical
Appointment Systems: A Systematic Review. Journal of Medical Internet
Research, 19(4), e134–e134. https://doi.org/10.2196/jmir.6747
|
Copyright
holder: Nadiya Nabila, Dumilah Ayuningtyas (2024) |
|
First
publication right: Asian Journal of
Engineering, Social and Health (AJESH) |
|
This
article is licensed under: |